Subjects

Subjects

More

Search

AI Knowunity

Subjects

/

Religious Studies

/

Component 1: philosophy of religion and ethics

/

Section a: philosophy of religion

/

Evil and suffering

The Problem of Evil: Easy Summary for A-Level Philosophy

View

The Problem of Evil: Easy Summary for A-Level Philosophy
user profile picture

Jasmine Fellows

@jasminefellows_slen

·

125 Followers

Follow

The problem of evil is a central challenge in philosophy of religion, questioning how an omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent God could allow evil and suffering to exist. This concept is crucial in a level philosophy courses, particularly when studying theodicies like the Augustinian and Irenaean approaches. The debate encompasses both the logical and evidential problems of evil, with various philosophers offering responses and critiques.

Key points:

  • The logical problem of evil questions the consistency of God's attributes with the existence of evil
  • The evidential problem of evil argues that the amount of evil in the world makes God's existence improbable
  • Theodicies attempt to reconcile God's existence with evil, including Augustine's free will defense and Irenaeus' soul-making theodicy
  • Critiques of these theodicies raise issues of fairness, scientific accuracy, and the nature of suffering

28/06/2022

516

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

View

The Evidential Problem of Evil

The evidential problem of evil focuses on the probability of God's existence given the amount and types of evil observed in the world. This approach is less absolute than the logical problem but still presents a significant challenge to theism.

Definition: The evidential problem of evil argues that the existence of evil makes God's existence improbable, rather than logically impossible.

Key points:

  • It acknowledges that evil exists and questions whether an omniscient, omnibenevolent, and omnipotent God would allow it.
  • One response is that we cannot know what an omniscient God would do, making comparison difficult.

Example: Natural disasters, diseases, and human cruelty are often cited as evidence in the evidential problem of evil.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

View

Augustine's Theodicy

Augustine's theodicy, also known as the Augustinian theodicy, attempts to explain the existence of evil while maintaining God's perfection and omnipotence.

Key elements of Augustine's theodicy:

  1. God created everything perfectly, as stated in Genesis.
  2. Evil is not a creation of God but a privation of good (privatio boni).
  3. The Fall of angels and humans introduced evil through free will.

Quote: "Free will is the cause of our doing evil" - Augustine

Augustine argues that free will is vital for genuine love of God, justifying its existence despite the potential for evil.

Highlight: The concept of Original Sin is central to Augustine's explanation of ongoing evil and suffering in the world.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

View

The Fall and Natural Evil

Augustine's theodicy extends to explain natural evil through the concept of The Fall. This event, according to Christian theology, disrupted the natural order and introduced suffering into the world.

Key points:

  1. Adam and Eve's disobedience led to the Fall.
  2. Natural evil is a consequence of human sin.
  3. Original Sin continues to affect humanity, justifying ongoing punishment.

Quote: "Thy just judgement is the cause of our having to suffer the consequences" - Augustine

Criticisms of this approach include:

  • Scientific inaccuracies regarding human origins
  • Logical contradictions in the perfection of creation
  • Questions about God's foreknowledge of evil

Example: Schleiermacher argued that either the world was created imperfect or God allowed it to go wrong, presenting a logical issue for Augustine's theodicy.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

View

Irenaean Theodicy and Soul-Making

The Irenaean theodicy, also known as the soul-making theodicy, offers an alternative explanation for the existence of evil. This approach, developed by Irenaeus and later expanded by John Hick, suggests that evil serves a purpose in human development.

Key aspects of the Irenaean theodicy:

  1. The world was created with evil to allow humans to develop into mature beings.
  2. Evil allows us to appreciate good and learn moral lessons.
  3. Free will is essential for genuine moral growth.

Quote: "How, if we had no knowledge to the contrary, could we have instruction in that which is good?" - Irenaeus

John Hick's contributions:

  • Introduced the concept of "epistemic distance" - God's hiddenness allows for genuine faith.
  • Proposed the idea of continued moral development after death.
  • Argued for universal salvation as a justification for earthly suffering.

Highlight: The Irenaean theodicy emphasizes the importance of human free will and moral development in justifying the existence of evil.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

View

Critiques and Philosophical Debates

The problem of evil and its various theodicies continue to be subjects of intense philosophical debate. Critics raise several important points:

  1. Unequal distribution of suffering: Some people suffer far more than others, challenging the fairness of a soul-making process.
  2. Negative effects of suffering: Not all people are improved by hardship; some are made worse.
  3. Issues with universal salvation: It may undermine the significance of earthly morality and Jesus' sacrifice.
  4. The scale of suffering: Dostoevsky argued that no amount of good could justify the suffering of even one child.

Quote: "One of them has been right all the time and the other wrong" - John Hick, on the parable of the celestial city

These ongoing debates highlight the complexity of the problem of evil and its central importance in a level philosophy and religious studies. The various approaches, from Augustinian to Irenaean theodicies, offer rich material for analysis in OCR a level questions and essays on the logical and evidential problems of evil.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

View

The Logical Problem of Evil

The logical problem of evil, as formulated by Epicurus, presents an inconsistent triad of God's attributes and the existence of evil. This challenges the traditional concept of an omniscient, omnipotent, and omnibenevolent God.

Definition: The logical problem of evil argues that the existence of evil is logically incompatible with an all-knowing, all-powerful, and all-good God.

Responses to this problem include:

  1. Deism: The idea that God created the universe but does not intervene.
  2. Plantinga's Free Will Defense: Argues that it's logically impossible for God to create free beings without the possibility of evil.
  3. Richard Swinburne's approach: Suggests that God cannot logically give us significant freedom without allowing for the possibility of evil.

Highlight: The concept of evil as a privation of good (privatio boni) is a key element in some responses to the problem of evil.

Similar content

Know Full mark Bonhoeffer essay thumbnail

13

439

12/13

Full mark Bonhoeffer essay

Example essay for Christian Moral Action topic for Ocr philosophy and ethics alevel

Know relation between kamma and tanha thumbnail

1

127

S5/S6

relation between kamma and tanha

Higher RMPS

Know The Problem of evil thumbnail

20

374

12/13

The Problem of evil

Detailed overview of OCR RS Alevel topic of the problem of evil

Know Augustine on Human Nature thumbnail

3

69

12/13

Augustine on Human Nature

Topic 1 for Development in Christian Thought. Brief summary notes on Augustine's views on human nature with a wide range of evaluations.

Know Origins of universe thumbnail

5

168

S5/S6

Origins of universe

Higher RMPS

Know Plato and Aristotle thumbnail

3

193

12/13

Plato and Aristotle

A detailed sheet on OCR RS Alevel Plato and Aristotle ancients topic

Can't find what you're looking for? Explore other subjects.

Knowunity is the #1 education app in five European countries

Knowunity has been named a featured story on Apple and has regularly topped the app store charts in the education category in Germany, Italy, Poland, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom. Join Knowunity today and help millions of students around the world.

Ranked #1 Education App

Download in

Google Play

Download in

App Store

Knowunity is the #1 education app in five European countries

4.9+

Average app rating

15 M

Pupils love Knowunity

#1

In education app charts in 12 countries

950 K+

Students have uploaded notes

Still not convinced? See what other students are saying...

iOS User

I love this app so much, I also use it daily. I recommend Knowunity to everyone!!! I went from a D to an A with it :D

Philip, iOS User

The app is very simple and well designed. So far I have always found everything I was looking for :D

Lena, iOS user

I love this app ❤️ I actually use it every time I study.

Sign up to see the content. It's free!

Access to all documents

Improve your grades

Join milions of students

By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Subjects

/

Religious Studies

/

Component 1: philosophy of religion and ethics

/

Section a: philosophy of religion

/

Evil and suffering

The Problem of Evil: Easy Summary for A-Level Philosophy

user profile picture

Jasmine Fellows

@jasminefellows_slen

·

125 Followers

Follow

The problem of evil is a central challenge in philosophy of religion, questioning how an omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent God could allow evil and suffering to exist. This concept is crucial in a level philosophy courses, particularly when studying theodicies like the Augustinian and Irenaean approaches. The debate encompasses both the logical and evidential problems of evil, with various philosophers offering responses and critiques.

Key points:

  • The logical problem of evil questions the consistency of God's attributes with the existence of evil
  • The evidential problem of evil argues that the amount of evil in the world makes God's existence improbable
  • Theodicies attempt to reconcile God's existence with evil, including Augustine's free will defense and Irenaeus' soul-making theodicy
  • Critiques of these theodicies raise issues of fairness, scientific accuracy, and the nature of suffering

28/06/2022

516

 

12/12

 

Religious Studies

15

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

The Evidential Problem of Evil

The evidential problem of evil focuses on the probability of God's existence given the amount and types of evil observed in the world. This approach is less absolute than the logical problem but still presents a significant challenge to theism.

Definition: The evidential problem of evil argues that the existence of evil makes God's existence improbable, rather than logically impossible.

Key points:

  • It acknowledges that evil exists and questions whether an omniscient, omnibenevolent, and omnipotent God would allow it.
  • One response is that we cannot know what an omniscient God would do, making comparison difficult.

Example: Natural disasters, diseases, and human cruelty are often cited as evidence in the evidential problem of evil.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

Augustine's Theodicy

Augustine's theodicy, also known as the Augustinian theodicy, attempts to explain the existence of evil while maintaining God's perfection and omnipotence.

Key elements of Augustine's theodicy:

  1. God created everything perfectly, as stated in Genesis.
  2. Evil is not a creation of God but a privation of good (privatio boni).
  3. The Fall of angels and humans introduced evil through free will.

Quote: "Free will is the cause of our doing evil" - Augustine

Augustine argues that free will is vital for genuine love of God, justifying its existence despite the potential for evil.

Highlight: The concept of Original Sin is central to Augustine's explanation of ongoing evil and suffering in the world.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

The Fall and Natural Evil

Augustine's theodicy extends to explain natural evil through the concept of The Fall. This event, according to Christian theology, disrupted the natural order and introduced suffering into the world.

Key points:

  1. Adam and Eve's disobedience led to the Fall.
  2. Natural evil is a consequence of human sin.
  3. Original Sin continues to affect humanity, justifying ongoing punishment.

Quote: "Thy just judgement is the cause of our having to suffer the consequences" - Augustine

Criticisms of this approach include:

  • Scientific inaccuracies regarding human origins
  • Logical contradictions in the perfection of creation
  • Questions about God's foreknowledge of evil

Example: Schleiermacher argued that either the world was created imperfect or God allowed it to go wrong, presenting a logical issue for Augustine's theodicy.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

Irenaean Theodicy and Soul-Making

The Irenaean theodicy, also known as the soul-making theodicy, offers an alternative explanation for the existence of evil. This approach, developed by Irenaeus and later expanded by John Hick, suggests that evil serves a purpose in human development.

Key aspects of the Irenaean theodicy:

  1. The world was created with evil to allow humans to develop into mature beings.
  2. Evil allows us to appreciate good and learn moral lessons.
  3. Free will is essential for genuine moral growth.

Quote: "How, if we had no knowledge to the contrary, could we have instruction in that which is good?" - Irenaeus

John Hick's contributions:

  • Introduced the concept of "epistemic distance" - God's hiddenness allows for genuine faith.
  • Proposed the idea of continued moral development after death.
  • Argued for universal salvation as a justification for earthly suffering.

Highlight: The Irenaean theodicy emphasizes the importance of human free will and moral development in justifying the existence of evil.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

Critiques and Philosophical Debates

The problem of evil and its various theodicies continue to be subjects of intense philosophical debate. Critics raise several important points:

  1. Unequal distribution of suffering: Some people suffer far more than others, challenging the fairness of a soul-making process.
  2. Negative effects of suffering: Not all people are improved by hardship; some are made worse.
  3. Issues with universal salvation: It may undermine the significance of earthly morality and Jesus' sacrifice.
  4. The scale of suffering: Dostoevsky argued that no amount of good could justify the suffering of even one child.

Quote: "One of them has been right all the time and the other wrong" - John Hick, on the parable of the celestial city

These ongoing debates highlight the complexity of the problem of evil and its central importance in a level philosophy and religious studies. The various approaches, from Augustinian to Irenaean theodicies, offer rich material for analysis in OCR a level questions and essays on the logical and evidential problems of evil.

The Problem of Evil J.S. Mill nature kills' LOGICAL PROBLEM D • Epicurus • inconsistant triad omniscient evit? if God is willing to prevent

The Logical Problem of Evil

The logical problem of evil, as formulated by Epicurus, presents an inconsistent triad of God's attributes and the existence of evil. This challenges the traditional concept of an omniscient, omnipotent, and omnibenevolent God.

Definition: The logical problem of evil argues that the existence of evil is logically incompatible with an all-knowing, all-powerful, and all-good God.

Responses to this problem include:

  1. Deism: The idea that God created the universe but does not intervene.
  2. Plantinga's Free Will Defense: Argues that it's logically impossible for God to create free beings without the possibility of evil.
  3. Richard Swinburne's approach: Suggests that God cannot logically give us significant freedom without allowing for the possibility of evil.

Highlight: The concept of evil as a privation of good (privatio boni) is a key element in some responses to the problem of evil.

Similar content

Religious Studies - Full mark Bonhoeffer essay

Example essay for Christian Moral Action topic for Ocr philosophy and ethics alevel

13

439

1

Know Full mark Bonhoeffer essay thumbnail

Religious Studies - relation between kamma and tanha

Higher RMPS

1

127

0

Know relation between kamma and tanha thumbnail

Religious Studies - The Problem of evil

Detailed overview of OCR RS Alevel topic of the problem of evil

20

374

0

Know The Problem of evil thumbnail

Religious Studies - Augustine on Human Nature

Topic 1 for Development in Christian Thought. Brief summary notes on Augustine's views on human nature with a wide range of evaluations.

3

69

0

Know Augustine on Human Nature thumbnail

Religious Studies - Origins of universe

Higher RMPS

5

168

1

Know Origins of universe thumbnail

Religious Studies - Plato and Aristotle

A detailed sheet on OCR RS Alevel Plato and Aristotle ancients topic

3

193

0

Know Plato and Aristotle thumbnail

Can't find what you're looking for? Explore other subjects.

Knowunity is the #1 education app in five European countries

Knowunity has been named a featured story on Apple and has regularly topped the app store charts in the education category in Germany, Italy, Poland, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom. Join Knowunity today and help millions of students around the world.

Ranked #1 Education App

Download in

Google Play

Download in

App Store

Knowunity is the #1 education app in five European countries

4.9+

Average app rating

15 M

Pupils love Knowunity

#1

In education app charts in 12 countries

950 K+

Students have uploaded notes

Still not convinced? See what other students are saying...

iOS User

I love this app so much, I also use it daily. I recommend Knowunity to everyone!!! I went from a D to an A with it :D

Philip, iOS User

The app is very simple and well designed. So far I have always found everything I was looking for :D

Lena, iOS user

I love this app ❤️ I actually use it every time I study.