Subjects

Careers

Open the App

Subjects

Understanding Direct and Indirect Realism in Philosophy

Open

25

0

user profile picture

cion ratna

11/12/2022

Religious Studies

DIRECT REALISM - Philosophy

Understanding Direct and Indirect Realism in Philosophy

Direct realism in philosophy examines how we perceive and understand reality through our senses. This comprehensive overview explores the fundamental principles, arguments, and challenges of direct realism in epistemology.

Direct realism posits that we perceive physical objects and their properties directly, without intermediary mental representations

• The theory supports immediate access to reality through sensory perception, avoiding skepticism

• Key challenges include arguments from illusion, perceptual variation, and hallucination

• Responses to criticisms focus on explaining apparent discrepancies while maintaining direct perception

...

11/12/2022

530

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

View

Responses to Challenges Against Direct Realism

Direct realists have developed responses to the challenges posed by illusions and perceptual variations. They argue that these phenomena don't necessarily refute the core claims of direct realism in philosophy.

Highlight: Direct realists don't have to suppose that objects must appear exactly as they are in all circumstances.

The response to the illusion argument suggests that:

  1. We are directly aware of the real object e.g.,thestrawe.g., the straw.
  2. The object's appearance e.g.,bente.g., bent is due to circumstances, not an intermediary entity.
  3. The "appearing" is not another thing mediating between the perceiver and the object.

Vocabulary: 'Sense data' refers to the hypothetical mental images or representations that some philosophers argue mediate our perception of external objects.

The argument from perceptual variation poses another challenge:

P1: Direct realism claims we directly perceive material objects and their properties. P2: The appearances of physical objects can vary depending on perception conditions. P3: The objects themselves don't vary. C: Therefore, direct realism is false; we must distinguish appearances from reality.

Example: Bertrand Russell concluded that we only directly perceive appearances or sense data, and must infer the existence and properties of real objects.

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

View

Berkeley's Example and Responses to Perceptual Variation

Berkeley's example of lukewarm water presents another challenge to direct realism:

P1: Direct realism claims material objects possess mind-independent properties we directly perceive. P2: Material objects are perceived to have incompatible properties e.g.,waterfeelingbothwarmandcolde.g., water feeling both warm and cold. P3: Objects cannot possess incompatible properties in reality. C: Therefore, direct realism is false.

Example: Lukewarm water can feel warm to a cold hand and cold to a warm hand, seemingly possessing incompatible properties.

However, direct realists offer responses to this challenge:

  1. We perceive the properties of objects as they really are.
  2. Objects may appear differently to perceivers while still being directly perceived.
  3. The appearance is a property of the object itself, not a separate entity.

Highlight: Direct realists argue that it is a property of lukewarm water to appear warm to a cold hand and cold to a warm hand.

These responses aim to explain perceptual variations within the framework of direct realism:

  1. We can explain why water feels warm or cool based on the relative temperature of our hands.
  2. Similar explanations can be developed for other examples of perceptual variation.
  3. We rarely find ourselves in disagreement about these perceptions in everyday life.

Quote: "We can explain why water feels warm or cool - because of the temperature of our hands relative to that of the water."

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

View

The Challenge of Hallucination to Direct Realism

The phenomenon of hallucination poses a significant challenge to direct realism in philosophy. The argument from hallucination can be structured as follows:

P1: Hallucinations occur when a person perceives something that doesn't exist outside the mind. C1: Therefore, what they perceive exists only in their mind. P2: Hallucinations can be subjectively indistinguishable from genuine perceptions.

Definition: A hallucination is a perception of something that does not exist in the external environment.

This argument challenges direct realism because:

  1. It suggests that some perceptions are entirely mental and not directly of external objects.
  2. If hallucinations are indistinguishable from real perceptions, it raises doubts about the reliability of all perceptions.

Highlight: The challenge of hallucination strikes at the core of direct realism by suggesting that some perceptions have no corresponding external object.

Direct realists must address this challenge to maintain their position that we directly perceive external objects. Possible responses might include:

  1. Arguing that hallucinations are fundamentally different from normal perceptions.
  2. Suggesting that hallucinations involve the perception of real mental objects, distinct from external physical objects.
  3. Proposing that hallucinations are not truly perceptions but a different kind of mental state altogether.

Example: A person hallucinating a pink elephant is not perceiving an actual external object, which seems to contradict the claims of direct realism.

The debate surrounding hallucinations and their implications for direct realism continues to be a significant topic in the philosophy of perception and epistemology.

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

View

Page 5: [No content provided for page 5]

Can't find what you're looking for? Explore other subjects.

Knowunity is the #1 education app in five European countries

Knowunity has been named a featured story on Apple and has regularly topped the app store charts in the education category in Germany, Italy, Poland, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom. Join Knowunity today and help millions of students around the world.

Ranked #1 Education App

Download in

Google Play

Download in

App Store

Knowunity is the #1 education app in five European countries

4.9+

Average app rating

21 M

Pupils love Knowunity

#1

In education app charts in 17 countries

950 K+

Students have uploaded notes

Still not convinced? See what other students are saying...

iOS User

I love this app so much, I also use it daily. I recommend Knowunity to everyone!!! I went from a D to an A with it :D

Philip, iOS User

The app is very simple and well designed. So far I have always found everything I was looking for :D

Lena, iOS user

I love this app ❤️ I actually use it every time I study.

 

Religious Studies

530

11 Dec 2022

5 pages

Understanding Direct and Indirect Realism in Philosophy

user profile picture

cion ratna

@cionratna_bchd

Direct realism in philosophy examines how we perceive and understand reality through our senses. This comprehensive overview explores the fundamental principles, arguments, and challenges of direct realism in epistemology.

Direct realismposits that we perceive physical objects and their... Show more

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

Sign up to see the contentIt's free!

Access to all documents

Improve your grades

Join milions of students

By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Responses to Challenges Against Direct Realism

Direct realists have developed responses to the challenges posed by illusions and perceptual variations. They argue that these phenomena don't necessarily refute the core claims of direct realism in philosophy.

Highlight: Direct realists don't have to suppose that objects must appear exactly as they are in all circumstances.

The response to the illusion argument suggests that:

  1. We are directly aware of the real object e.g.,thestrawe.g., the straw.
  2. The object's appearance e.g.,bente.g., bent is due to circumstances, not an intermediary entity.
  3. The "appearing" is not another thing mediating between the perceiver and the object.

Vocabulary: 'Sense data' refers to the hypothetical mental images or representations that some philosophers argue mediate our perception of external objects.

The argument from perceptual variation poses another challenge:

P1: Direct realism claims we directly perceive material objects and their properties. P2: The appearances of physical objects can vary depending on perception conditions. P3: The objects themselves don't vary. C: Therefore, direct realism is false; we must distinguish appearances from reality.

Example: Bertrand Russell concluded that we only directly perceive appearances or sense data, and must infer the existence and properties of real objects.

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

Sign up to see the contentIt's free!

Access to all documents

Improve your grades

Join milions of students

By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Berkeley's Example and Responses to Perceptual Variation

Berkeley's example of lukewarm water presents another challenge to direct realism:

P1: Direct realism claims material objects possess mind-independent properties we directly perceive. P2: Material objects are perceived to have incompatible properties e.g.,waterfeelingbothwarmandcolde.g., water feeling both warm and cold. P3: Objects cannot possess incompatible properties in reality. C: Therefore, direct realism is false.

Example: Lukewarm water can feel warm to a cold hand and cold to a warm hand, seemingly possessing incompatible properties.

However, direct realists offer responses to this challenge:

  1. We perceive the properties of objects as they really are.
  2. Objects may appear differently to perceivers while still being directly perceived.
  3. The appearance is a property of the object itself, not a separate entity.

Highlight: Direct realists argue that it is a property of lukewarm water to appear warm to a cold hand and cold to a warm hand.

These responses aim to explain perceptual variations within the framework of direct realism:

  1. We can explain why water feels warm or cool based on the relative temperature of our hands.
  2. Similar explanations can be developed for other examples of perceptual variation.
  3. We rarely find ourselves in disagreement about these perceptions in everyday life.

Quote: "We can explain why water feels warm or cool - because of the temperature of our hands relative to that of the water."

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

Sign up to see the contentIt's free!

Access to all documents

Improve your grades

Join milions of students

By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

The Challenge of Hallucination to Direct Realism

The phenomenon of hallucination poses a significant challenge to direct realism in philosophy. The argument from hallucination can be structured as follows:

P1: Hallucinations occur when a person perceives something that doesn't exist outside the mind. C1: Therefore, what they perceive exists only in their mind. P2: Hallucinations can be subjectively indistinguishable from genuine perceptions.

Definition: A hallucination is a perception of something that does not exist in the external environment.

This argument challenges direct realism because:

  1. It suggests that some perceptions are entirely mental and not directly of external objects.
  2. If hallucinations are indistinguishable from real perceptions, it raises doubts about the reliability of all perceptions.

Highlight: The challenge of hallucination strikes at the core of direct realism by suggesting that some perceptions have no corresponding external object.

Direct realists must address this challenge to maintain their position that we directly perceive external objects. Possible responses might include:

  1. Arguing that hallucinations are fundamentally different from normal perceptions.
  2. Suggesting that hallucinations involve the perception of real mental objects, distinct from external physical objects.
  3. Proposing that hallucinations are not truly perceptions but a different kind of mental state altogether.

Example: A person hallucinating a pink elephant is not perceiving an actual external object, which seems to contradict the claims of direct realism.

The debate surrounding hallucinations and their implications for direct realism continues to be a significant topic in the philosophy of perception and epistemology.

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

Sign up to see the contentIt's free!

Access to all documents

Improve your grades

Join milions of students

By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Page 5: [No content provided for page 5]

PERCEPTION AS A SOURCE OF KNOWLEDGE
DIRECT REALISM:
There are two elements in perception:
PERCEIVER and OBJECT PERCEIVED
Direct realism reje

Sign up to see the contentIt's free!

Access to all documents

Improve your grades

Join milions of students

By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy

Direct Realism: Perception as a Source of Knowledge

Direct realism in philosophy posits that perception involves two key elements: the perceiver and the object perceived. This theory rejects the notion of 'sense data' as intermediaries between the perceiver and the external world. Instead, it asserts that we directly and immediately perceive physical objects and their properties.

Definition: Direct realism is the philosophical view that the external world exists independently of the mind, and we perceive it directly without intermediaries.

The core tenets of direct realism include:

  1. Physical objects are mind-independent
  2. Our senses detect properties of these objects directly
  3. Objects retain their properties even when unperceived

Example: When a tree falls in a forest with no one around, it still makes a sound according to direct realism, as the sound is a property of the falling tree, not dependent on perception.

Support for direct realism comes from several angles:

  1. It avoids skepticism by providing a clear account of how we gain knowledge of the world.
  2. It has explanatory power for our ability to interact with the world effectively.
  3. It explains the regularity and predictability of our perceptions.
  4. It aligns with our intuition that we share a common reality with others.

Highlight: Direct realism explains why we agree about what we perceive and supports our sense that we occupy the same universe as everyone else.

However, direct realism faces challenges, particularly from the argument from illusion:

P1: In an illusion, an object appears to have a property it doesn't possess. P2: The perceiver is directly aware of this apparent property. P3: The object doesn't have this property in reality. C1: What the perceiver is directly aware of and what is real are distinct. C2: Therefore, direct realism is false.

Example: A straight straw half-immersed in water appears bent, challenging the notion that we directly perceive the straw's true properties.

Can't find what you're looking for? Explore other subjects.

Students love us — and so will you.

4.9/5

App Store

4.8/5

Google Play

The app is very easy to use and well designed. I have found everything I was looking for so far and have been able to learn a lot from the presentations! I will definitely use the app for a class assignment! And of course it also helps a lot as an inspiration.

Stefan S

iOS user

This app is really great. There are so many study notes and help [...]. My problem subject is French, for example, and the app has so many options for help. Thanks to this app, I have improved my French. I would recommend it to anyone.

Samantha Klich

Android user

Wow, I am really amazed. I just tried the app because I've seen it advertised many times and was absolutely stunned. This app is THE HELP you want for school and above all, it offers so many things, such as workouts and fact sheets, which have been VERY helpful to me personally.

Anna

iOS user

Best app on earth! no words because it’s too good

Thomas R

iOS user

Just amazing. Let's me revise 10x better, this app is a quick 10/10. I highly recommend it to anyone. I can watch and search for notes. I can save them in the subject folder. I can revise it any time when I come back. If you haven't tried this app, you're really missing out.

Basil

Android user

This app has made me feel so much more confident in my exam prep, not only through boosting my own self confidence through the features that allow you to connect with others and feel less alone, but also through the way the app itself is centred around making you feel better. It is easy to navigate, fun to use, and helpful to anyone struggling in absolutely any way.

David K

iOS user

The app's just great! All I have to do is enter the topic in the search bar and I get the response real fast. I don't have to watch 10 YouTube videos to understand something, so I'm saving my time. Highly recommended!

Sudenaz Ocak

Android user

In school I was really bad at maths but thanks to the app, I am doing better now. I am so grateful that you made the app.

Greenlight Bonnie

Android user

very reliable app to help and grow your ideas of Maths, English and other related topics in your works. please use this app if your struggling in areas, this app is key for that. wish I'd of done a review before. and it's also free so don't worry about that.

Rohan U

Android user

I know a lot of apps use fake accounts to boost their reviews but this app deserves it all. Originally I was getting 4 in my English exams and this time I got a grade 7. I didn’t even know about this app three days until the exam and it has helped A LOT. Please actually trust me and use it as I’m sure you too will see developments.

Xander S

iOS user

THE QUIZES AND FLASHCARDS ARE SO USEFUL AND I LOVE THE SCHOOLGPT. IT ALSO IS LITREALLY LIKE CHATGPT BUT SMARTER!! HELPED ME WITH MY MASCARA PROBLEMS TOO!! AS WELL AS MY REAL SUBJECTS ! DUHHH 😍😁😲🤑💗✨🎀😮

Elisha

iOS user

This apps acc the goat. I find revision so boring but this app makes it so easy to organize it all and then you can ask the freeeee ai to test yourself so good and you can easily upload your own stuff. highly recommend as someone taking mocks now

Paul T

iOS user

The app is very easy to use and well designed. I have found everything I was looking for so far and have been able to learn a lot from the presentations! I will definitely use the app for a class assignment! And of course it also helps a lot as an inspiration.

Stefan S

iOS user

This app is really great. There are so many study notes and help [...]. My problem subject is French, for example, and the app has so many options for help. Thanks to this app, I have improved my French. I would recommend it to anyone.

Samantha Klich

Android user

Wow, I am really amazed. I just tried the app because I've seen it advertised many times and was absolutely stunned. This app is THE HELP you want for school and above all, it offers so many things, such as workouts and fact sheets, which have been VERY helpful to me personally.

Anna

iOS user

Best app on earth! no words because it’s too good

Thomas R

iOS user

Just amazing. Let's me revise 10x better, this app is a quick 10/10. I highly recommend it to anyone. I can watch and search for notes. I can save them in the subject folder. I can revise it any time when I come back. If you haven't tried this app, you're really missing out.

Basil

Android user

This app has made me feel so much more confident in my exam prep, not only through boosting my own self confidence through the features that allow you to connect with others and feel less alone, but also through the way the app itself is centred around making you feel better. It is easy to navigate, fun to use, and helpful to anyone struggling in absolutely any way.

David K

iOS user

The app's just great! All I have to do is enter the topic in the search bar and I get the response real fast. I don't have to watch 10 YouTube videos to understand something, so I'm saving my time. Highly recommended!

Sudenaz Ocak

Android user

In school I was really bad at maths but thanks to the app, I am doing better now. I am so grateful that you made the app.

Greenlight Bonnie

Android user

very reliable app to help and grow your ideas of Maths, English and other related topics in your works. please use this app if your struggling in areas, this app is key for that. wish I'd of done a review before. and it's also free so don't worry about that.

Rohan U

Android user

I know a lot of apps use fake accounts to boost their reviews but this app deserves it all. Originally I was getting 4 in my English exams and this time I got a grade 7. I didn’t even know about this app three days until the exam and it has helped A LOT. Please actually trust me and use it as I’m sure you too will see developments.

Xander S

iOS user

THE QUIZES AND FLASHCARDS ARE SO USEFUL AND I LOVE THE SCHOOLGPT. IT ALSO IS LITREALLY LIKE CHATGPT BUT SMARTER!! HELPED ME WITH MY MASCARA PROBLEMS TOO!! AS WELL AS MY REAL SUBJECTS ! DUHHH 😍😁😲🤑💗✨🎀😮

Elisha

iOS user

This apps acc the goat. I find revision so boring but this app makes it so easy to organize it all and then you can ask the freeeee ai to test yourself so good and you can easily upload your own stuff. highly recommend as someone taking mocks now

Paul T

iOS user