The Demise of the Pilgrimage of Grace

The Pilgrimage of Grace ultimately failed due to King Henry VIII's cunning tactics and military response. This page details the events leading to the rebellion's downfall and its consequences.

Negotiation and Deception

1. The Duke of Norfolk, outnumbered by the rebels, negotiated with Robert Aske at Doncaster Bridge.

2. Norfolk promised to take the rebels' demands directly to King Henry VIII.

3. A month later, the demands were presented, including a request for Parliament to meet in York for better representation.

4. The rebels were told to go home with a pardon from the king.

Highlight: Henry VIII's strategy was to separate Aske from the rebels and distract him while secretly preparing a military response.

The King's Betrayal

1. In December 1536, Aske spent Christmas with Henry at Greenwich Palace, where the king assured him of support for the rebels' cause.

2. Simultaneously, Henry was strengthening his garrison in the north, revealing his true intentions.

3. Realizing the king's deception, some rebels decided to act first, attacking castles in Hull, Beverley, and Scarborough in January 1537.

Example: This premature action gave Henry an excuse to cancel the pardons he had previously granted.

Consequences of the Rebellion

The failure of the Pilgrimage of Grace had significant repercussions:

Political Consequences

1. Henry had Lord Darcy, Lord Hussey, and Robert Aske executed.
2. The Council of the North was strengthened to assert royal authority.
3. No more rebellions occurred during Henry's reign.
4. Thomas Cromwell eventually fell out of favor and was executed in 1540.

Economic Consequences

1. The economy improved with money from dissolved monasteries.
2. Henry was able to develop the Royal Navy.
3. Landowners bought former monastery lands.

Religious Consequences

1. The dissolution of monasteries continued.
2. In 1539, many larger monasteries were dissolved.

Vocabulary: Dissolution - The formal ending or breaking up of an assembly, partnership, or official body.

Why Did the Pilgrimage of Grace Fail?

The rebellion's failure can be attributed to several factors:

1. Henry VIII's deceptive tactics in negotiating with the rebels.
2. The premature actions of some rebels, giving Henry an excuse to retaliate.
3. The king's superior military strength once he had time to organize his forces.
4. The lack of sustained unity among the rebels once they were sent home with false promises.

Quote: "The rebellion had been squashed." This simple statement encapsulates the ultimate fate of the Pilgrimage of Grace, despite its initial promise and widespread support.