Government Policies: Breaking Promises and Native Resistance
The US government's approach to Plains Indians was a masterclass in broken promises and failed policies. The 1830 Indian Removal Act forced 46,000 Native Americans west of the Mississippi, supposedly for their "protection."
The 1834 Permanent Indian Frontier promised Plains Indians their own territory - except it wasn't permanent at all. When the 1851 Indian Appropriations Act pushed for assimilation, the government basically said "live like white Americans or else."
The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1851 seemed reasonable enough - each tribe got defined territory, settlers could cross safely, and tribes received $50,000 worth of goods yearly for 50 years. Problem solved, right?
Wrong. Neither side kept their promises due to language barriers, tribal disagreements, and the government's sneaky move in 1857 to cut payments from 50 years to just 10. This betrayal increased Native American resentment whilst white settlement exploded in California and Oregon, threatening everything Plains Indians held sacred.
The Bottom Line: These policies marked the end of the Permanent Indian Frontier and set the stage for decades of conflict as two completely different ways of life collided on the Great Plains.