Cultural Variations in Attachment Research
Three major studies have shaped our understanding of how attachment patterns differ across cultures. Van IJzendoorn & Kroonenberg's groundbreaking 1988 meta-analysis examined 32 studies from 8 countries, involving nearly 2,000 children using Ainsworth's Strange Situation procedure.
Their findings revealed that whilst secure attachment was most common everywhere (ranging from 50% in China to 75% in Britain), there were significant variations. Resistant attachment was least common overall but varied dramatically - just 3% in Britain compared to 30% in Israel. Germany showed the highest rates of avoidant attachment, whilst Japan had the lowest.
Perhaps most surprisingly, variations within the same country were 150% greater than differences between countries. Some US studies found 46% secure attachment whilst others found 90% - suggesting that local cultural practices matter more than national identity.
Key Insight: Cultural child-rearing practices within countries can create bigger differences in attachment than comparing entirely different nations.
More recent studies by Jin (2012) in Korea and Simonella (2014) in Italy have supported these patterns. The Italian study particularly highlighted how cultural changes - like more mothers working and using childcare - can reduce secure attachment rates, showing that attachment patterns aren't fixed but evolve with society.